When it comes to construction, containment is essential to ensure the safety of workers and the public. In a nutshell, containment refers to the practice of keeping harmful elements within limits. This can be achieved using various methods, such as traditional construction containment methods or shrink wrap. Traditional construction containment methods, such as scaffolding containment, are often used in jobs that require dust suppression, asbestos removal, or metal paint and blast. On the other hand, shrink wrap is a popular choice for keeping unwanted elements out, such as rain.

Pros and Cons of Construction Containment Methods

In the construction industry, there are several methods used to protect or contain work areas. In this blog post, we will take a closer look at the pros and cons of each method to help you determine the best option for your project. Whether you opt for traditional containment methods or choose to explore the benefits of shrink wrap, our goal is to help you make an informed decision that will ensure the success of your project.

Tarpaulin Cover Construction Containment Method

Pros:

1. Cost-effective – Tarpaulins can be purchased at most local hardware stores at a very reasonable price.
2. High Tear Resistance – Some of the new fabrics used in tarpaulin covers are extremely strong, making them ideal for construction use.
3. Readily Available – There are no waiting lists to purchase this product, making it convenient for construction projects.
4. Easy Installation – Tarpaulin covers come with built-in eyelets, making it very easy to tie them down over a structure or scaffold system.
5. Reusability – Tarpaulins of good quality can be reused on other jobs, making them a sustainable choice.

Cons:

1. Uncertified – Most tarpaulin installations are carried out without the advice of an engineer, which could pose safety risks due to extra wind loads created.
2. Noise – Tarpaulin covers can flap around in the wind, causing loud and disruptive noises that can be annoying to workers and neighbours trying to sleep at night.
3. Difficult Installation – Tarpaulin covers are only easy to install on uniform shaped structures, making it difficult to get a tight, waterproof seal on irregularly shaped structures and scaffolds.
4. Non-flame Retardant – Most tarpaulin covers are not flame retardant, which could pose safety risks on construction sites.

Timber and Sheet Metal Containment Structure

Pros:

1. High Strength – Structures made of timber and sheet metal roof are known for their strength and durability, ensuring the protection of the construction site and workers.
2. Customisable – These structures can be custom-built to any shape, allowing for a perfect fit to the specific job requirements.
3. Sustainable – A large portion of the material used in timber and sheet metal structures can be recycled and repurposed on other projects, making them an eco-friendly option.

Cons:

1. Expensive – The cost of purchasing timber and metal can be high, which may not be feasible for all construction projects.
2. Time-Consuming – These structures can take a longer time to construct and dismantle compared to other temporary containment methods.
3. Not Flame Retardant – Timber is a flammable material, and as a result, these structures may not be safe in certain construction environments.
4. Disposal of Materials – Disposing of materials from these structures after the project is finished can be expensive due to the weight, or they may need to be stored for a future project, taking up valuable space.

Shrink Wrap Containment

Pros:

1. Cost-effective – Shrink wrap containment is a more affordable alternative to traditional timber and metal sheeting, making it a great value for money option.
2. Adaptable – Unlike other containment solutions, shrink wrap can be easily cut and welded to fit around irregularly shaped structures.
3. Quiet – Properly installed shrink wrap does not make noise from flapping and banging in the wind.
4. Fast installation – Our expert installers can install hundreds of square metres of shrink wrap in just one shift.
5. Engineering support – Our team of engineers can provide guidance and sign off on larger installations, giving you peace of mind.
6. Flame retardant – Our shrink wrap material is superior in terms of flame resistance, making it a safer option.
7. Durable – Our thicker material provides excellent strength and durability for long-lasting containment.
8. Aesthetically pleasing – The smooth, shiny surface of shrink wrap provides a visually appealing finish.

Cons:

1. Expert Installation Required – Unlike tarpaulin, shrink wrap requires experienced tradesmen to install it safely and correctly. Our installers have over 20 years of experience.
2. Dry Weather Installation – Shrink wrap cannot be installed in wet or damp conditions, requiring dry weather to ensure proper adhesion.

Construction Containment Solutions – Pros and Cons

In conclusion, when it comes to choosing a containment solution for your construction or renovation project, there are various options available to you. Each option comes with its own set of advantages and disadvantages, which need to be considered before making a decision. Tarpaulin, timber & metal sheeting and shrink wrap are three popular options for containment, each with its own unique features.

High Quality Shrink Wrap Containment

If you are looking for a containment solution that is quick to install, strong, flame retardant, and aesthetically pleasing, then shrink wrap may be the ideal choice for you. With experienced installers, our team at Stronghold Hire can provide you with a high-quality shrink wrap service. Enquire about our shrink wrap service today by sending us an email at info@strongholdhire.com.au or contact us online.